Feeding your dog a diet free of processed foods and grains can significantly improve digestion and overall health. When considering a raw diet for your dog, two prominent options are the BARF (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food) diet and the PMR (Prey Model Raw) diet.
Both diets aim to provide biologically appropriate nutrition for dogs, yet they have distinct differences. Let's explore the main aspects of each diet to help you determine which one might be the best fit for your dog.
What is the BARF Diet?
The BARF diet, which stands for Biologically Appropriate Raw Food, focuses on feeding dogs a diet that closely resembles what their wild ancestors would eat. This diet includes:
-
Raw meaty bones or bone in mince: Provides essential proteins and minerals.
-
Muscle meat: The primary source of protein.
-
Organ meats: Rich in vitamins and minerals.
-
Fresh fruits and vegetables: Adds variety, dietary fibre and essential nutrients.
-
Occasional additions: Eggs and dairy products like raw goat’s milk or pot set Greek yogurt.
The BARF diet aims to provide a balanced nutritional profile by combining a variety of animal and plant-based ingredients.
Including vegetables and fruits in a dog's diet can provide additional vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and fibre, which could otherwise be lacking from the diet. It can also be particularly beneficial for dogs with specific dietary needs or deficiencies.
While some critics argue that dogs, being primarily carnivorous, do not need vegetables and fruits, proponents believe these additions can enhance overall health and allow for a more nutritionally balanced diet.
What is the Prey Model Raw (PMR) Diet?
The PMR diet, or Prey Model Raw diet, takes a more specific approach by focusing on feeding dogs whole prey animals. This diet is based on the idea that dogs should eat as their wild ancestors did, without the inclusion of plant matter.
This diet includes:
-
Muscle meat: Makes up about 80% of the diet.
-
Raw edible bones: About 10% of the diet.
-
Organ meats: Liver and other secreting organs make up about 10% of the diet.
The PMR diet excludes plant-based ingredients. It is important to consider that the absence of plant matter means all nutrients must come from animal sources. This can be challenging to balance and may require careful planning to ensure nutritional adequacy.
Key Differences Between BARF and PMR
-
Ingredient Variety: The BARF diet includes a mix of raw meat, bones, organ meats, and plant-based ingredients, while the PMR diet focuses solely on whole prey animals.
-
Nutritional Balance: The BARF diet aims to provide a balanced diet by combining different types of food, whereas the PMR diet relies on the natural balance found in whole prey animals.
-
Ease of Preparation: The BARF diet can be easier to prepare as it allows for a mix of raw and commercially prepared ingredients, while the PMR diet requires sourcing whole prey animals, which can be more challenging.
-
Nutrient Content: The PMR diet is often higher in certain nutrients like vitamin A and arachidonic acid due to the inclusion of whole prey animals, while the BARF diet often is higher in dietary fibre and antioxidants due to the inclusion of plant matter.
Which is Better: BARF or PMR?
The choice between BARF and PMR largely depends on your dog's specific needs and your personal preferences. Here are some factors to consider:
-
Nutritional Needs: If your dog has specific dietary requirements or deficiencies, the BARF diet's inclusion of vegetables and supplements might be beneficial.
-
Philosophical Alignment: If you believe in a more natural, ancestral diet for your dog, the PMR diet might be more appealing.
-
Practicality: Consider the ease of sourcing ingredients and preparing meals. The BARF diet might require more variety and supplementation, but the PMR diet focuses on whole animals and animal products which can at times be difficult to source. Feeding whole animals can also be more confronting than feeding a BARF style diet.
Choosing between the BARF and PMR diets depends on your dog's specific needs, your lifestyle, and your ability to source ingredients. The BARF diet offers more flexibility and may be easier to manage, while the PMR diet provides a more natural approach but requires more effort to source whole prey animals. Ultimately, both diets can be healthy and beneficial if properly balanced and tailored to your dog's needs.
